Monday 15 February 2021


A horrified dog walker spoke of her disgust after coming upon a number of deer lying butchered at a popular Highland beauty spot on land owned by a conservation charity.

The female was walking her dog on January 27th in the Nevis Gorge area near Fort William when she found the bloodied torsos of hinds lying dumped in public view on ground owned by John Muir Trust.

Distressed at seeing a female and a calf lying in unnatural positions with back ends cut out, she spoke to a friend who suggested she contacted The Scottish Gamekeepers Association (SGA).

The SGA has ruled out poaching due to the way the deer have been butchered, and understands the cull will have been part of the charity’s deer management activity.

In 2011, the SGA called a meeting with the charity after it left 40 dead deer in public view at Ben Nevis, shocking access takers.

It feels that conservation bodies leaving carcasses to rot in public cheapens an iconic species and sends a damaging message as efforts are being made to champion Scottish wild venison. 

The gamekeepers’ group also believe such images of carved up deer will turn the public against deer managers who are doing great conservation work across the country, reducing red deer populations in recent years.

“The lady didn’t want publicity but she was very upset and asked that we look into it because she loves seeing deer. She was basically disgusted,” said SGA Chairman Alex Hogg.

“The area is well visited and what surprised her most was that this was the last thing she thought she would find in an area owned by a nature conservation charity.”

The images were taken within sight of Steall Bothy, around 50 yards off the main walking track.

Best practice certification for deer managers states that carcasses in such proximity to buildings and public areas should be removed.

John Muir Trust’s controversial deer management approach was in the spotlight 5 years ago.

In 2016, the SGA wrote an Open Letter to the First Minister seeking a Parliamentary inquiry after 86 Stags were left to rot on a Knoydart hillside, some with haunches and heads removed.

The charity’s stalkers culled and left the animals, which were found by walkers, and claimed the deer were too difficult to extract at Li and Coire Dhorcail.

In Assynt, local crofters and land managers clashed with Trust deer controllers after over 400 missing deer were reported following heavy Trust culls, leading to significant lost crofter income.

“Every few years these things seem to happen on John Muir Trust ground. It is not isolated, sadly,” said Bill Cowie of the SGA Deer Group. “Regarding the deer in the photographs, there may have been some access problems extracting them from one side but it is known there is access out from the other. Do the public really want to see this when taking daily exercise? If not, they should write to their MSPs.

“There are families in dire straits, with big demand at food banks. The venison left could have fed a family for weeks. 

“Scottish Government has just given £50 000 to promote venison. Is this the signals Scotland should be sending about a resource Government says needs developing?”

*John Muir Trust has claimed the deer were 'dragged from the hill for a photograph' by individuals hostile to them. The individual who sent the SGA the photos did not drag deer from the hill for a photograph. 

If anyone in the local area has more information or concerns about deer culling practice in this area, they can contact the SGA on

Thursday 4 February 2021


 Gamekeepers seek talks with community group on Mountain Hare translocation proposal

Mountain hare on managed moorland by Michael Callan.

Gamekeepers plan to speak to the group behind the Langholm community buy-out to discuss a scheme to return the iconic mountain hare to its former moorland home.

The Langholm Initiative completed south Scotland’s biggest ever community buy-out when it purchased 5200 acres of Langholm Moor, Tarras Valley and associated properties from Buccleuch Estates for £3.8m last October.

Legal paperwork was due for completion on January 31st, with the group seeking to create Tarras Valley Nature Reserve, which they hope will become a haven for nature.

Now gamekeepers in neighbouring upland areas hope to set up a meeting with the group to discuss the possibility of hares being reintroduced to the moor to kick-start a regional recovery.

The mountain or ‘blue’ hare is Scotland’s only native hare and was a common sight at Langholm when the moor was managed for red grouse shooting.

Now fully protected, the native hares became extinct at the site around the early 2000s after gamekeepers had lost their jobs following the Joint Raptor Study (1), undertaken at Langholm.

Despite mountain hares’ conservation status now being classed as ‘unfavourable’, driven grouse moors in nearby Lammermuir and Moorfoot hills boast a healthy surplus.

Their plan is to discuss the potential for them to act as ‘donors’ to help re-boot the species where they were once a cherished part of the moorland fauna.

Hares would be ‘live trapped’ on grouse moors to be translocated to moorlands with appropriate habitat, in a bid to re-develop a breeding population.

Similar translocations, which follow a conservation Code, have allowed beavers to be captured and moved from parts of Scotland where they cause significant damage to farmland.

This has allowed other regions to benefit, also reducing numbers of problem animals potentially culled under licence.

“Mountain hares were common when gamekeepers worked at Langholm. There is potential for a win-win, here, for returning lost species, for Reserve visitors to enjoy and for getting hares back to favourable conservation status in Scotland,” said Alex Hogg, Chairman of The Scottish Gamekeepers Association.

“There is a willingness for gamekeepers to discuss this with the community group and we hope a virtual meeting can take place after they get their feet under the desk.

“If all the tests can be met, we could see mountain hares back at Langholm. That would be a special achievement. If they were to re-establish successfully, it could also have a longer term benefit as a food source for the golden eagles which have been reintroduced to the south of Scotland.”

While gamekeepers have been criticised for culling mountain hares, research shows grouse moors can house populations up to 35 times more abundant than non-managed moorland due to predator management and legal burning of heather which renews their food supply (1)*.

When hares reach high densities on grouse moors, however, they become highly susceptible to disease caused by gut worms which can see them die off in large numbers as it spreads.

“Now that the new laws to protect mountain hares are passed, there is no longer an ability to control hare populations on our moors,” said Mark Ewart, Co-Ordinator of The Southern Uplands Moorland Group.

“It makes sense to use surplus populations from grouse moors to try to re-establish the species elsewhere, or to build up fragmented populations so they become more resilient.

“Research points to there being not enough recruitment, in areas away from grouse moors, to sustain the species in the longer run. Rather than watch them die on our moors from disease, which is pointless, it makes sense to use the surplus to help the species recover.”

*(1) Spatial and temporal variation in mountain hare abundance in relation to red grouse management in Scotland

  • The Joint Raptor Study was carried out between 1992 and 1997. It concluded that raptor predation at Langholm reduced Autumn red grouse abundance by 50%, which led to the cessation of commercially viable grouse shooting. Gamekeepers lost their jobs and in the intervening years between the Joint Raptor Study and the Langholm Moor Demonstration Project (2008 to 2018)- (when no gamekeepers were employed)- mountain hares disappeared from the moor, Hen Harriers declined from 20 to 2 and Wading birds also disappeared.

  • Mountain hares were introduced to the Western Isles, Orkney and Shetland in earlier centuries. They are a favoured food source for eagles and wildcats. Current evidence suggests there is little sign of mountain hare increases in other areas of Scotland beyond grouse moor core areas and, as hares do not disperse naturally beyond one mile or so, bolstering populations with no or low densities could produce a net conservation gain. Translocation is also an alternative to lethal control which is acceptable to the conservation community.